Acer Aspire 5920 user review
Posted by
Michael Walsh) on Jul 12 2007 | Tagged as: Acer, Gemstone
I have decided to turn the tables completely. After all, blogs are about opinions, feedback and free dialogue so what better way to support this than asking someone who actually bought an Acer laptop to reviews it and publish it here? No journalist bias or marketing spin. Just the facts…
Jing Yeow was fast enough to get his hands on one of the first Aspire 5920s in the UK and kind enough to agree to write his thoughts down for The Acer Guy so my thanks to him first and foremost.
I haven’t been able to download his photos yet as my net speed is painfully slow at the moment but I’ll update the article and post add them the moment I get back to the office.
The photos are all Jing’s too.
Enjoy.

The Acer Aspire 5920G is the flagship model for the new Acer Gemstone Series. It has a fresh new design modelled on (yes you guessed it) a gemstone and takes advantage of the latest notebook technology, including many features attributed to the new Centrino Pro platform. The Aspire model seems to be a model for the mainstream consumer who requires value for money as well as placing high importance on design.

This is in part a response to HP’s excellent design credentials when it comes to producing stylish notebooks the consumer requires, and you can recognise Acer has taken a few ideas out of their consumer line with the glossy black finish on the outer notebook.

The reason why I chose this notebook was because it reached the top mid range of my budget. I could have stretched to £999 if I had to, but soon realised for the money spent I would be getting the same notebook at a higher price and in some cases, fewer features than the Acer 5920. Before deciding on this notebook, I had looked extensively at the HP dv2500t series as the design suited me perfectly, but it was let down by price and hardware. It costs just £100 less than the Acer. Whilst the newer dv6000t costs £100 more than the Acer Gemstone, but again with no turbo memory and only a 8400M dedicated card.
Essentially it boiled down to a portable HP, or a feature packed Acer, and the Acer won by miles. This is a multimedia machine, and if that is important to you, the Acer fulfils a lot of needs.

I purchased this off a UK retailer online as they were the first to stock this model of notebook. It cost £799.97 which was the reviewed price, which is great value for a notebook of this specification and price point, but where Bluetooth was in reviewed samples, it failed to make it to the final release, meaning there is a dummy Bluetooth button just on top of the unpressable dummy button below it on the left hand side of the notebook.
The exterior is a beautiful rich glossy black, which looks hard wearing, but remains hollow in the very centre where there remains some flex, none of which affect the screen due to the distance of the outer-shell to the screen. The edges of the notebook are hard plastic that offer no flex at all and is reasonable protection for the screen in a backpack.

The interior is very pretty when first viewed. The design is impactful and the colour scheme is a creamy white depending on the light conditions. Admittedly under artificial light this can appear more beige, but it is relaxing on the eyes.
The keyboard is extremely comfortable to use. The travel is short, which user preference would class as a love or hate feature. There is no flex on the left hand side of the keyboard, but significant flex on the right hand side of the keyboard, around the 7-8 numerical keys and all those below. However, this has no impact on typing regardless of speed on key impact.

The mouse pad glides smoothly and is a synaptics device. The mouse buttons are a much different breed. They are loud and would be heard in a quiet room when one wishes to be covert. You will need to learn to use the touch pad to click if you wish totally silent operation.

The notebook itself is very sturdy and rigid. The plastic inside offers superb protection for the components, and provides ample space for the wrists. No flex or creaking here. The left hand side of the notebook stays warm through basic tasks such as word processing, or viewing pictures, but can get wildly hot when gaming.
I have noticed that newer games tend to put more stress on the Nvidia 8600M GT and thus increase the heat. Older games, such as Sim City 4, put less stress on the GPU.

There are buttons on either side of the notebook keyboard, performing a variety of quick functions. Significant to note is the Wireless Lan button. Notice this is a button, and there is little chance of it becoming worn out like the “switches” on other notebooks such as the Vaio, or the PSP wireless switch which can lead to one not being able to connect to the other devices.
The downside is that the touch sensitive control cannot (to my knowledge) be reprogrammed. For example, the “record” button only opens the pre-installed NTI CD/DVD Maker 7, whilst I am sure many would prefer it to launch Nero or perhaps Ashampoo alternatives.

The media flow line actually a small part of the notebook, that rests above the keyboard and only lights up when charging, CPU processing or when Caps of Num Lock are turned on. The light does not flow throughout the whole keyboard surface as you may have seen in some promotional videos.

The speaker grill is a stylish silver and remains my favourite feature of the notebook. I have heard the speakers on a Toshiba Quisio and whilst it matches it on clarity, the quisio was extremely weak on bass, where the Acer 5920 easily surpasses it.
Playing games becomes incredibly immersive with directional sound, and surround sound “effects” that work adequately. Personally I think these are much better to have than not, but they are nothing to shout about.

Battery Life is an aspect of this notebook I have not tested extensively. Whilst watching Wimbledon, I decided to leave the notebook on whilst writing parts of this review and surfing the internet intermittently with screen brightness on 50% and wireless enabled (Default Balanced ePower Managements settings away from Mains).
The result was 2 hours into the Federer/Nadal Final with the notebook reporting 36% battery life remaining (However accurate that is). I didn’t test it till shut off, but from that I can estimate near enough 3 hours of battery life on the road. I have it confirmed that the battery is a 6 cell. This may even be longer with power saver that would have reduced the CPU speed and downed the screen brightness a tad. The screen is unviewable with 0% brightness, and I recommend 40% if you want it to remain useable without straining the eyes too much.

The screen is beautiful to look at…if you view it dead on centre. The colours are vibrant and outlines sharp from the glossy CrystalBrite screen. I would have preferred matte as reflections will be your worst enemy if using this notebook with you back to sunlight. Viewing angles horizontally are decent.
Text remains readable at 45 degrees off-centre but the colours darken at around 20 degrees from centre. Vertical angles are much worse with colours appearing washed out immediately when viewed above, and darkening just as quickly when viewed below centre. Backlighting is generally even, with a little leakage at the bottom which is not noticeable unless viewing a screen.

For those of you who use Skype, this notebook is the perfect companion. Its video functionality is especially good and doubles up as a adequate still camera, taking low-res, but visually distinguishable shots. The dual microphones also do a good job of video conferencing as it detects sound/voices from sources over a metre away clearly according to a few Skype Test Calls.
| 3.0 (9 people) |
on 13 Jul 2007 at 6:30 pm 1
Jam (Check me out!) said …
Hi Michael, is possible if you could pass this question onto Jing please, thanks.
In media centre, can you locate the TV options as I have heard other users saying that they are not able to find them in the menu, thanks.
—–
Jam.
on 13 Jul 2007 at 8:33 pm 2
Michael Walsh (Check me out!) said …
If I’m not mistaken Jing will be checking this. I’ll make sure he gets pinged though.
on 14 Jul 2007 at 12:23 am 3
Jing (Check me out!) said …
Hi, I won’t pretend I know how to use Media Center, and in truth I’ve opened it once or twice.
Do you wish to know if I can see this screen?
http://www.mediacenteroem.com/newsite/mediacenter/2.jpg
If so, do I require a tv tuner to get access to this option?
I don’t see anything related to TV. Acer Arcade has infiltrated its way into WMC though allowing video editing, and the viewing of camcorder videos which may stop “My TV” options appearing, else it may simply be because I do not have a tv tuner.
I have however, experienced conflicts with other Acer programs so I wouldn’t rule out the possibility that Acer’s own software is to blame for those users that have experienced problems finding “Tv Options” in their WMC.
Sorry I can’t be more help.
on 14 Jul 2007 at 7:45 pm 4
Jam (Check me out!) said …
Hi Jing,
Yeh, you’ve been getting the same problem as other 5920 users. Acer Arcade wipes out the TV options in the MC menu. If you un-install Acer Arcade, the TV options should pop up as they should do.
Sos Michael if I keep asking you too many questions but, could you tell this issue to Acer for us? (whenever you have time). Is there anyway in having Acer Arcade installed whilst also being able to use MC’s TV options?
Thanks.
—–
Jam.
on 17 Jul 2007 at 12:48 pm 5
Michael Walsh (Check me out!) said …
Jam,
Simone’s just weighed in on your question. I won’t pretend I know what he’s talking about but hope it helps you out
on 17 Jul 2007 at 8:02 pm 6
Jam (Check me out!) said …
Hi Jing, and other users experiencing the same problem.
I’ve found a way to fix the Acer Arcade and TV options conflict.
————————————————-
Goto Computer\HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\Media Center\Start Menu:
Change “HideTV” value to 0
————————————————-
Credit for this needs to go to ‘Klas’ of notebookreview.com
Enjoy.
Jam.
on 17 Jul 2007 at 8:40 pm 7
Michael Walsh (Check me out!) said …
Don’t you just love it when things just work straight out of the box…?
Thanks Jam and kudos to Klas.
on 19 Jul 2007 at 12:55 am 8
Jing (Check me out!) said …
Hi again, just wondering if any other owners of this notebook has a similar “problem” to me.
If you take a look a the image above the paragraph
“The speaker grill is a stylish silver…” in my review, you will notice that the start of the grill is in focus and goes out of focus as you travel along its length in the photograph. Now as the grill strip moves out of focus you notice that the colour of the small black specks turns into a patch of white, and continues black again.
I’ve found this is because the mesh here is different to the black mesh that covers the rest of the speakers. Is this a problem? It looks like the builders ran out of material, and when they resumed; missed out some speaker grills. However further down that speaker strip there is a single speck (unviewable in the photographs) that is the same white mesh. So I dont think its intentional.
Whilst not possible to tell, could it mean no sound is coming out of that area? Should I be worried? I dont like it when uniformality is interrupted. So this issue bugs me.
Sorry its not a more interesting comment ;D.
on 20 Jul 2007 at 6:33 pm 9
Mark Garlick (Check me out!) said …
Hi, nice review. I am tempted to buy this but I worry about your description of viewing angles. Quoting figures doesn’t really help. Would this laptop be okay for two people to watch movies on, side by side? Or would the low viewing angle mean the image for each person would be washed out since each will of course be off centre?
Thanks in advance. If only I knew of a physical show where I could actually see this computer.
on 20 Jul 2007 at 11:15 pm 10
Michael Walsh (Check me out!) said …
Mark,
Don’t know what country you’re writing from but if it’s the UK you’ve got Comet (and soon Tesco’s) to choose from. Looks like Comet’s stocking the Bluetooth version.
If you’re from the States, it’s available from Best Buy.
Failing that let me know where you’re from and I’ll try and hunt it down.
As for the viewing angles, I’d rather Jing or someone who’s actually tried to watch a film in bed on the 5920 answer your question.
However, my wife and I did that for about two years on an old (ie no CrystalBrite) TravelMate and we had ball.
We stopped because a 750MB bootleg just doesn’t contain the audio-visual clarity I want. However, with Dolby in on the game I’m sure the experience is now very, very different.
on 21 Jul 2007 at 7:00 pm 11
Jing (Check me out!) said …
Viewing angles are not that bad for two people watching side by side. You will both see pretty much the same thing on the screen in regards to colour and clarity or picture. What I really tried to emphasise were the above/below viewing angles, which are poor like many laptops.
The real problem will be the height of the notebook relative to the viewer. My desk is about 1/3 of a meter taller than my bed mattress. When lying back on the bed, the picture goes very dark. If standing up, the screens colour looks washed out. The easy solution to this, is very easily to tilt the screen forwards or backwards until suitable. Until there is an easier way to do this, I guess you’ll have to do the “tilt screen, check if the picture is alright from the sofa, go back again if its not quite right, then see if it looks okay from the sofa…etc..”
Under my rough estimates I think you could pack about 6-8 people side by side watching a movie without anyone complaining “we can’t see anything!!”
*I wouldn’t put money on Comet stocking the bluetooth one. Firstly, I have doubts it would cost £799, as that would annoy existing buyers and Comet Spec Sheets are rarely to be relied upon.
Amazon UK have also got stock earlier than they anticipated. Again, no mention of bluetooth, so I assume it is abscent from there too.
on 21 Jul 2007 at 10:52 pm 12
Michael Walsh (Check me out!) said …
Jing,
Sorry man I missed your question above about the speaker grill.
I haven’t been able to track down a 5920 to compare or a white paper on the dolby speakers to understand the layout but I know what you mean about how discontinuity an drive you to distraction.
The official photos also look like yours might have a slight defect but remember these are usually production-ready prototypes and should not therefore be taken as “the final product”.
If it really bugs you, go down to Comet and compare yours with what they’ve got on sale. If you’re right and yours has a defect, get onto Laptopsdirect and see what they say.
on 22 Jul 2007 at 9:59 pm 13
Mark Garlick (Check me out!) said …
Thanks for the replies, Jing and Michael. I am in the UK. I did not know Comet were stocking it, so I’ll check them out — there is a big branch nearby. The website has no image of it but it says it has Bluetooth, and it’s listed at £799 (£899 in-store price).
Cheers. Am also looking at the Dell inspiron 1520. Very similar specs. Still unsure which to go for.
on 23 Jul 2007 at 8:02 am 14
Michael Walsh (Check me out!) said …
Hi Mark,
For the sake of fairness, I should point you to this reply from Richard@DELL over on another post.
Can’t accuse me of bias
on 24 Jul 2007 at 10:19 am 15
mos (Check me out!) said …
Hi
I was wondering about the Acer Aspire 5920 interior color and if it gets dirtier easily or what? since the color is closer to be white than grey, i was also wondering about the Dell inspiron 1520 featuring geforce 8600m gt would it be a better buy (I frankly don’t kknow how much would it cost so please someone inform me) and also what about the Asus F3SV (1350$-1600$) and Asus G1s (1800$-1900$), I frankly think that even the Asus F3sv is better in terms of build quality than the Acer and that only the Acer beats the F3sv and inspiron 1520 in terms of performance, and unfortunately the Acer 5920 also doesn’t look great!!
on 24 Jul 2007 at 10:41 am 16
Michael Walsh (Check me out!) said …
Hi Mos,
I’m not the person to ask these sorts of questions. And I think the only person who could tell you something more about the dirtyness-factor of the interior is Jing who’s actually got one himself.
As to the comparisons, have a look at Richard’s reply (link above) and then go to Dell’s site and configure one yourself. Every time I do it the one I would build ends up costing about twice the price of the 5920 but then if you’re going to upsell (which Dell does brilliantly) the outcome is bound to be different.
Asus? have a look here at where they came from. The products might be seem great but don’t you get that “copycat feeling” about them? There. I just shot myself in the fair comparison foot.
Looks? The guys that designed the 5920 also designed the new Mini and if ever there was a modern icon that has divided the style opinions of the buying public, the Mini is it. You either love it or loathe it and nobody can do a damned thing about it.
For me the jury’s still out although I would be lying if I said I had one nearby. The closest I get is the photos I see online…
on 24 Jul 2007 at 11:49 am 17
Nick (Check me out!) said …
Hi Michael and Jing,
I am also considering buying this laptop and most likely will. I have just one more question which has not been answered yet on any review I read:
Apparantly, under the battery there is a SIM-card reader. Have any of you gotten it to work yet? I have no found any Acer information on this subject, either.
Obviously this is not really important, but could be very useful to me.
Thanks!
on 24 Jul 2007 at 3:05 pm 18
Michael Walsh (Check me out!) said …
Hi Nick,
As far as I know, the intergated SIM card reader is only featured on the 3G notebooks like the .
I’ve pulled up the spec sheet for the AS5920 and can’t find it mentioned anywhere. Of course that doesn’t mean it won’t be fitted at some point in the future but for now, based on what I’ve seen, it looks like you’ve been misled
on 24 Jul 2007 at 3:36 pm 19
Nick (Check me out!) said …
Hi again,
Please allow me to rephrase. I _know_ the SIM card reader is in (I have read this in several reviews and have even seen pictures - so it is comfirmed by several people) just nobody has gotten it to work yet. I can hardly imagine it’s in as a dummy SIM slot.
For picture reference: http://brick19.hyves.org/80250001-80300000/80294301-80294400/80294332_5_J3aJ.jpeg
More info on the subject: http://gathering.tweakers.net/forum/list_messages/1229806/1 (it’s in Dutch, though)
One of the guys in there also mentions that he can not find any information on the subject in the Acer manuals that came along with the laptop. In other words, nobody has yet figured out how to use it or why it is there. Hence why I was wondering whether perhaps any of you had information.
Thanks!
on 24 Jul 2007 at 3:44 pm 20
mos (Check me out!) said …
thank you michael for your reply, I am planning to buy a new laptop in the next few months and acer 5920 tops my list among dell 1520, asus f3sv and asus g1s
well michael i’ll have to disagree with you about the dell 1520 price because i personlly configured it more than one time and it always costs from 1350$- 1500$ fully loaded (t7300, 2 gb ram, 160 gb hd, 8600m gt, integrated webcam).
you also didn’t convince me about the asus issue.
here are the things i hate about acer aspire 5920 and i hope jing himself tells me more about each point:
1-interior color is white which would look like garbage after 1 year or so unless it was made from superior materials
2-the usb port beside the dvd drive is ok for me but the usb logo is printed in the wrong place!!
3-web cam looks cheap and is only 0.3 m pixel
4- heats up more than other models
on 24 Jul 2007 at 4:23 pm 21
Jing (Check me out!) said …
In the UK (The land off the rip-off) I configured the 1520 to the Acer 5920 specs, with differences in webcam (2mp as opposed to 0.3) and 9 cell battery as opposed to 8 cell.
It costs 946.80 with delivery and a free printer which they make you purchase a cable for.
There are differences which you have pointed out Mos, but they seem pretty baseless.
The interior is not the type that will fade or change colour. It wont pick up scratches, only smudges and dirt from the wrist area, which can be wiped away with a damp cloth. I can’t think of another product that uses this material, but it feels like injection moulded plastic.
For somebody that thinks the interior will look like garbage in a year. You do know that the Dell Silver wrist rests wear/fade away over time due to the chemical breakdown of the paint through contact with sweat/heat. Silver with
I cannot see how the usb logo is printed in the wrong place. It is directly above the port, and again on the keyboard surface of the laptop, so its easy to see where the usb ports are without having to look for the actual ports. (see picture 8 from the top in the review)
The web cam does not look cheap. It looks great without standing out. The resolution is low, but the camera regardless works well in all conditions, especially in low light.
It does get pretty hot when gaming on the left hand side. Nothin to say about that, but its not a big issue. A lot of heat is pumped out the back of the laptop. THey could have installed some ventilation on the left hand side of the notebook where the ports are, but would have had to put ports on the back of the laptop which would not have been good.
Things that are more annoying are:
When the lid is closed, one of the screen circular pads (which cushion the screen) presses directly against the left mouse button. This makes it click when pressure is applied on this section of the closed lid. Only design flaw I can think of.
The mouse buttons are awful. So noisy and the left seems to sink into the laptop. They are solid, but I wouldn’t use them unless I had to.
Bluetooth button does not work, but its so slow to me its useless, maybe its better it wasn’t included, as I am going to get a bluetooth v3 dongle which promises faster speeds (up to usb2) and the built in bluetooth may conflict, since everytime the laptop starts up, the wireless is automatically enabled. Probably the same with the bluetooth.
on 24 Jul 2007 at 4:34 pm 22
Michael Walsh (Check me out!) said …
Nick,
Emm. I don’t know how to say this. It seems you’re right.
Don’t quote me on this but it looks to all intents and purposes like a design feature that was proposed on the original prototype but that never made it through to final production on this model.
As far as anyone in Acer can tell me, it’s not active on this model and therefore it’s a dummy slot just like the Bluetooth button on non-Bluetooth models.
The only explanation I can give is the one the Acer UK guy gave me for the Bluetooth question. It might be a feature they bring in at some point (user demands/market needs, whatever) and as all the chassis are the same, it’s there on all of them right from the outset. Well spotted though!
on 24 Jul 2007 at 5:07 pm 23
Jing (Check me out!) said …
This might clarify the reason why that 3G slot does not work. It will probably be enabled on future laptops, as a way of maintaining the current price point. E.g. Instead of dropping the price, we’ll add a feature so we can continue charging the current price. Or else increase the price.
——–
“Acer currently maintain a wide variety of models of notebook computer in the current range, and for any given range of notebooks the onboard options may vary but, the case remains constant across the range for each series of notebook. This means that some machines will have case switches or connections that lack functionality. The most common of these are the Bluetooth and Wireless LAN toggles on the front of many of the cases.
Bluetooth usb dongles can be purchased for around £5-10 to add Bluetooth to your laptop.”
Acer Technical Support
on 24 Jul 2007 at 8:23 pm 24
Michael Walsh (Check me out!) said …
Blimey. Glad I didn’t write that bit of soulless twaddle - it clearly lacks the Pompey twang I try and put in all my pieces
on 24 Jul 2007 at 8:35 pm 25
Nick (Check me out!) said …
Alright, thanks for the answers and information guys!
on 25 Jul 2007 at 12:05 am 26
mos (Check me out!) said …
Thanks jing for your thorough analysis of your Aspire 5920
One more thing, would you please tell me the Asus F3sv and Asus G1s prices in the UK, and your personal opinion about both of them compared to the Aspire 5920.
on 25 Jul 2007 at 12:19 am 27
Iain (Check me out!) said …
I’m looking to buy the 5920, and have been having problems locating stock. I was pleasantly surprised to see you mention Comet is stocking the bluetooth version. Would you be able to ask Acer UK if the bluetooth version Comet’s stocking has the 1GB turbo memory - it doesn’t mention it on their website.
Cheers in advance!
on 25 Jul 2007 at 12:26 am 28
Iain (Check me out!) said …
Found the answer on Acer’s website - for anyone else that might have the same question, the answer is yes the 5920 version that Comet’s selling does have 1GB turbo memory.
on 25 Jul 2007 at 1:08 pm 29
Jing (Check me out!) said …
This is the absolute cheapest place (If not one of the only places) to get the Asus G1 and Asus F3SV. Since they are not sold in the high street.
G1S - £1219
http://www.nexus13.com/productcart/pc/viewPrd.asp?idcategory=340&idproduct=1124
F3SV - £879
http://www.nexus13.com/productcart/pc/viewPrd.asp?idcategory=306&idproduct=1121
The Asus G1S is superior to the Acer 5920, but that’s reflected in the price. Over £400 more than the Acer. If you need a high screen resolution and have the extra money to spare, this would do fine. Otherwise you are paying through the nose for a bit more processing power, slightly more powerful graphics and the design (which looks really tacky to me). However, the speakers are heavily criticised by everyone who owns it. Apparently too much echo and tinny.
The F3SV is at a more attractive price point, and I was considering this too, except at the time of purchasing a 5920, this cost £979 and had a built-in tv tuner, which has been discontinued in the model linked above.
The price is similar to the 5920 for features, but the real selling point over the 5920 is the fingerprint reader, bluetooth, swivel camera and Vista Ultimate (not to mention the free bag and mouse). Even when i weigh it against the 5920 now, the downsides still hold up.
Silver. Looks tacky and will rub off over time. 8600GS graphics card. Vastly inferior to the 8600GT. The design is not a touch on the 5920, no HDMI port. Battery life will be much lower than the 5920 owing to the 6 cell battery, whilst trying to run the same powerful core specifications.
If those features are important to you, the Asus F3SV is not a bad choice. If the 5920 did not exist, I would own a F3SV, as they second to Acer provide the best value for money around. People complain of the built quality on Asus’s F3 series, but they did the same with the Aspire series, which I have no issues with.
However, with the 5920 I got value for money as well as style, which is a bonus.
on 25 Jul 2007 at 6:00 pm 30
Chris (Check me out!) said …
Is the 5920 actually in any Comet store yet? I went into my local one today to be told that it “wasn’t on the system”
on 25 Jul 2007 at 6:43 pm 31
Adam (Check me out!) said …
Actually, the ASUS F3SV (AP073G) is cheapest at the following site (£850):
http://www.laptopsdirect.co.uk/Asus_F3SV_Laptop_F3SV-AP073G/version-1.asp
That’s just £50 over the Acer 5920 now (£30 really, as a decent laptop bag + optical mouse [free with Asus] would be around £20 extra for the 5920).
Also, the upgrade from Vista Home Premium to Vista Ultimate must be worth at least £60 surely? (and I want to upgrade to Ultimate at some point, as I need Fax, plus the file “previous versions” and other extra functionality would be very welcome).
So the F3SV is very tempting at the moment!
However, in terms of hardware specs, the Acer Aspire 5920 is still the better PC I think - I just wish the built-in Webcam was a bit better (say 1.3 megapixel instead of 0.3). I’m just waiting to see how much extra (if any) Acer and dealers will wamt for the bluetooth-enabled version (LX.AGW0X.169), and when it will be available.
I’m still trying to decide between the Acer Aspire 5920 (still top of my list at the mo!), a Dell Inspiron 1520 (with 8600M GT graphics and 1440 x 900 display, a better resolution for 15.4″ I think) and the Asus F3SV…
P.S. My local Comet (Carmarthen - quite a small store though) had no 5920’s in sight when I visited them today whilst out shopping!
on 25 Jul 2007 at 7:05 pm 32
Michael Walsh (Check me out!) said …
Hey guys,
Have you noticed I haven’t chimed in with a “WHAT ARE YOU THINKING”??
Two reasons: first I believe you are the better judge of what’s right for you. Second: I’ve got so much work on my plate at the moment that anything I say wouldn’t add to the conversation at all.
I’m still curious to know why Comet isn’t stocking the 5920 though. Aren’t any other stores like Dixons stocking it?
on 25 Jul 2007 at 8:50 pm 33
Adam (Check me out!) said …
Hi Michael,
Actually, we don’t have a Dixon’s near us - however, I may have a quick look in Curry’s and PC World next week or the week after - I would have thought that PC World would want to stock the 5920 at least! I’ll let you know if I come across any 5920’s “in the flesh” so to speak (would ideally love to see one at least before purchasing, if possible).
P.S. My “budget option” (that I may still purchase, if I decide that I don’t really need DirectX 10 graphics) is the Acer TravelMate 5720G (specifically, the 5720G-302G16 - LX.TK30X.033 - which seems like a bargain: 2GHz T7300 Core 2 Duo, 2GB RAM, 160GB HD, Webcam, 4 x USB2, 1 x FireWire, Dedicated Graphics - ATI Mobility Radeon X1700 with 256 Mb VRAM, etc, for around £650!).
Have you (or anyone else) seen any reviews of this yet? (I’ll still probably get the 5920 really, but if I decide my budget can’t take it, may go for the TravelMate 5720).
Anyway, I *probably* won’t be purchasing my laptop for the next 2 - 4 weeks at least (maybe a bit longer even), so have plenty of time yet to research and decide!
Thanks for the 5920 review by the way Jing - great job! And thanks to Michael too for the informed discussions & information. Cheers…
on 25 Jul 2007 at 10:11 pm 34
Michael Walsh (Check me out!) said …
Adam,
This is only the start. I expect everyone here to write their own reviews if and when they buy… That’ll guarantee the conversation gets interesting.
Jing gets my thanks too. Apart from a great review, he’s also put in some pretty fierce arguments and informed replies I wouldn’t have known where to begin looking for… The man rocks!
The TravelMate 5720 is a sturdy little thing. It’s got the new Magnesium Alloy case which gives it a solid, rigid feel but do remember that TravelMates are built primarily for business use (hence the grey) which usually means you get better battery life (big business need) but fewer multimedia features (not so important). Often you’ll find integrated graphics and shared memory on the TM range.
Need proof? Have a look at what Acer calls the “User Split”. You can see what I mean here. You decide who you are, and Acer provides what market research thinks is best suited to your needs. Business = TravelMates. Fun&Games = Aspires. Of course it never matches my own needs/tastes but then I’ve never slotted in anywhere. I see their point though…
The other thing I need to get off my chest is that this site is the last place you’re going to feel like you need to buy something from Acer to be welcome. I do that day in day out and this is where the real me lets off steam, blows my own trumpet, sings in the shower… that sort of thing.
It’s a chat among friends over a beer. OK the conversation does tend to focus on the pro’s and con’s of different graphics cards, OrbiCam woes and Comet Vs. Tesco’s but then nobody’s perfect!
I mean c’mon, I even got RichardATDELL to join in! How open is that??
on 01 Aug 2007 at 9:50 am 35
Jimmy (Check me out!) said …
Hi guys
Do you know if a 5920 model without HDDVD is available in USA ? I don’t prefer the HDDVD since its not yet the market leader and also without it I believe that 5920 can be accomodated in my budget..
on 01 Aug 2007 at 10:19 am 36
Michael Walsh (Check me out!) said …
Hi Jimmy,
I’ll get in touch with Acer USA and see what they have to say.
on 01 Aug 2007 at 10:40 am 37
Dennis (Check me out!) said …
If possible, I’d love to know if Acer will be producing a cheaper line of Santa Rosa based laptops.
For example, when will they be refreshing the 5630 line.
Thanks!
on 01 Aug 2007 at 12:02 pm 38
Michael Walsh (Check me out!) said …
Hi Dennis,
That’s the sort of information that right now I can’t give out, even if I had access to it.
All computer manufacturers trickle down technology at some point so there’s nothing to suggest Santa Rosa won’t be such a premium item in the future but “when?” is a 6 million dollar question.
Having said that, there are strategic moments throughout the year when IT companies introduce new models and update old ones. “Back to School” comes in September and then there’s Chirstmas so I’d look out for new products around then.
Oh, and keep your eyes on the forums - with the Gemstone they were way ahead of me!
Sorry I can’t help any more than that.
on 01 Aug 2007 at 10:04 pm 39
Nick K (Check me out!) said …
Hey, I’m looking into getting the 5920 aswell but I’m trying to get the bluetooth one really. I popped into my local Comet (In Telford) yesterday and did a bit of asking. They won’t be getting any in their warehouse until Thursday 2nd August, and then only the larger stores will be getting them in stock. If you look on their website though it says what size each store is and if they have full range/wide range etc.
I’m going to pop up to the Shrewsbury store tomorrow and see if they’ll be getting it in, and ask about the bluetooth, the guy I was talking to was adament the specs provided by Comet were accurate (he even printed them off the computer for me…) right up until I pointed out that firewire is standard, and they’ve got ‘not supported’.
Does anyone know where you can get the 8 cell battery for the 5920 though, because I don’t think the 6 cell will have quite long enough battery life…
on 02 Aug 2007 at 6:40 pm 40
Tom (Check me out!) said …
I just got home from patrol (USCG) to find my new Acer Aspire 5920-6313 waiting for me (this is the USA version). the short story: I really like it. the long story: well first off my card reader works just fine. it was one of the first things I tested. my model is different from the European version in that it only has a 1.5Ghz processor. so far it hasn’t seemed to be a hinderance though. I have the 8-cell battery (4800mAh). I also only have an A/B/G Wi-Fi card but all the hot spots in my town use B or G, so I don’t mind. I have the turbo memory, but not the blue tooth. still 2Gigs RAM and 160 Gig HDD. I also have the HD DVD/Dual layer DVD-RW. my price about $1100 (after tax) at Best Buy. I hit a sale, they’ve gone up $200 since then. still for the price this is a great piece of equipment. I have seen the 6661 advertised on web sites for 2400+ dollars. that seams high to me since all I need to do to have the same machine is buy a $300 processor and upgrade to draft N wi-fi. has anyone tried to open up the case to check out how easy it is to upgrade? it looks like it should be very easy, but I have yet to put a screw-driver to it. I’m thinking I’ll get 4 Gigs of RAM for it sooner rather than later.
on 03 Aug 2007 at 12:34 am 41
Michael Walsh (Check me out!) said …
Tom,
Welcome back on dry land!
Did you know that 22% of The Acer Guy’s readers are from the USA? Add on the 7% from Canada and you guys have got an overwhelming majority…
If you fancy doing a full review of your own, US-spec laptop, I’ll gladly publish it. I’m sure an awful lot of readers stateside would appreciate it too
on 04 Aug 2007 at 2:05 pm 42
Tan (Check me out!) said …
Hi,
I stumbled upon this forum and was hoping if you guys could perhaps answer a question regarding the 5920.
Does the model that Comet are stocking have the 1gb Turbo memory.
Many Thanks if you can help with this.
Tan
on 04 Aug 2007 at 7:39 pm 43
Nick (Check me out!) said …
Hey Tan, the Comet model doesn’t have the Turbo memory. I spent almost an hour altogether on the phone to Comet and Acer to find out.
)
Nobody at Acer seemed to have a clue (Well basically the guys I ended up talking to weren’t really bothered with helping) and the guys at Comet didn’t know. I finally got through to a guy at Comet who called some other people, who told him that Acer and Comet no longer have the same strong relationship so they only get the standard models on the Acer site, and as it has Bluetooth it doesn’t have turbo memory. (Apparently it definitely does have bluetooth, they were 100% about that much
I couldn’t believe how long it took to work all this out, I called Acer to make sure there were only 2 models available and they confirmed that you can only possibly get turbo memory